CRM partner selection

Questions to Ask a CRM Implementation Partner Before You Sign

Questions and red flags for choosing a CRM implementation or migration partner, what HubSpot and Salesforce badges certify, a scoring sheet and contract terms.

On this page

HubSpot partner tiers mostly measure what a firm sells and how much of that revenue it keeps, and Salesforce competencies rate the firm as a whole, which makes both badges a fair filter for a shortlist and a weak basis for the final pick. Who will map your records, rebuild your workflows and hand over the keys is a separate question, and the badge leaves it open. Our position: ask every bidder the same questions, score the answers on one sheet, and sign only when the contract leaves your company holding the data, the top admin account and the documentation.

What a HubSpot partner tier measures

HubSpot names four Solutions Partner tiers: Gold, Platinum, Diamond and Elite. The points behind them "are awarded per $100 USD MRR." Sourced points come from sourcing and closing deals, managed points from servicing existing customers, and for non-growth market customers a partner earns 5 sourced points for every $100 of sourced MRR. These are the bars to meet by January 15, 2027.

TierSourced pointsTotal pointsAverage gross revenue retention
Gold115345No minimum listed
Platinum4251,275No minimum listed
Diamond1,2503,750At least 75%
Elite2,75011,000At least 80%

At 5 points per $100, the Gold sourcing bar works out to $2,300 of monthly recurring revenue sourced from non-growth market customers, and Elite to $55,000, and sourced points expire one year after the deal closes. The skills requirement is lighter: "at least one employee at your company must pass the partner certification exam once every 25 months." Elite adds at least 100 user certifications among employees, and every tier requires good standing, defined as "no open escalations or past escalations."

Accreditations come closer to testing delivery. According to HubSpot, they are "earned at the organization level" and ask for prerequisite certifications, "a review of your team's qualifications," and evidence from customer engagements, "including case studies." The accreditation standards, also from HubSpot, say "Partners must be platinum, diamond or elite to apply for and retain an accreditation."

In the tier rules we read, we found no requirement tied to how many CRM migrations a partner has completed or to the documentation it leaves behind. Read a Diamond badge as evidence of sales volume and retention, and ask separately who will do your work.

What Salesforce partner levels and certifications measure

Salesforce's FY27 consulting program "moves to two tiers, Summit and Select," according to the Salesforce program brochure, which also swaps 170 Navigator distinctions for 28 outcome-based competencies. Each competency is measured by certifications, completed projects and customer satisfaction (CSAT), at two levels: Accredited ("Demonstrated capability") and Expert ("Scaled delivery excellence"). That sits closer to delivery than HubSpot's points, so the first check on a Salesforce bid is which competency the firm holds, at which level, for the cloud you are buying.

A competency belongs to the firm, and the certified consultants behind it may be staffed on another client. Individual certifications can be checked on Salesforce's verification tool, and Salesforce Help says others see the name, dates and description "only if your profile is public," so ask each named consultant to make theirs public. The brochure also lists Catalyst, an incentive to "Reward post-sale activation and consumption." A partner paid on consumption has reason to recommend more platform, so tie every add-on to a requirement you wrote.

Twelve questions to put to every bidder

Choosing a CRM implementation partner goes best with a fixed checklist of questions to ask every bidder in the same order, with the answers copied into the proposal as commitments.

  1. Who will work on our project, for what share of their week, and which of their certifications can we verify today?
  2. When did this team last migrate from our source system at a similar record count, and can we call that client?
  3. What does discovery produce, and do we keep it if we stop there?
  4. How will you decide which fields, objects and pipelines we keep, merge or retire, and who signs off?
  5. How many test migrations will you run, and how do you reconcile record counts and associations?
  6. What happens if the production load fails halfway through cutover?
  7. How do you treat duplicates, records owned by departed staff, and records with no reliable identifier?
  8. Which integrations use native connectors, middleware or custom code, and who maintains the code after go-live?
  9. If you build automated workflows or AI agents, what can they write to the CRM without a person approving it?
  10. Can we see a past handover pack, with the client's name removed?
  11. How will you train our administrator, and what support follows go-live?
  12. Whose name goes on the software subscription, and who holds the top admin account?

Question 9 belongs on the list whenever a proposal includes agentic AI inside the CRM. A good answer describes permissions, approval steps and a rollback path, the controls in our governance operating model for marketing agents, with the kind of human review steps laid out in our working setup for Claude.

What are the red flags in a CRM migration partner?

To evaluate a CRM migration or implementation partner for red flags, listen to how the questions above get answered. Each of these should lower a score, and two or three together should end the conversation.

  • The tier badge or competency is offered as the answer to who will do the work.
  • The delivery team stays unnamed until after signature.
  • The plan has one migration run, with no test load and no reconciliation report.
  • The partner wants the only top-level admin account or a shared login. On HubSpot, partner staff join through an access link the client approves and get Partner Admin permissions, which the HubSpot Knowledge Base says cannot add, remove, or downgrade Super Admins, change billing settings, make payments, or manage sensitive data.
  • The partner buys the subscription in its own name. The customer terms from HubSpot say: "If you are a HubSpot Solutions Partner that purchases on behalf of a client, you agree to be responsible for the Order Form and to guarantee payment of all fees." That puts a third party on the Order Form for your own CRM.
  • Mapping sheets, transformation scripts and configuration notes are called the partner's intellectual property.
  • Add-ons appear with no requirement behind them.

A scoring sheet that keeps the badge in proportion

Score each bidder from 1 to 5 per row, multiply by the weight, add the rows and divide by 5 for a score out of 100. The weights are our suggested starting point, an assumption to adjust for your project. Both bidders are hypothetical: Partner A is an accredited Diamond-tier firm with no named team and one migration run, and Partner B is a Gold-tier firm with three certified consultants, a same-source reference and two test loads.

CriterionWeightWhat a 5 looks likePartner APartner B
Named team20Every consultant named, certifications public, allocation stated25
Migration experience20Same source system, similar volume, a reference you can call34
Migration method20Test loads, reconciliation report, written rollback plan25
Handover15A sample handover pack shown in the pitch24
Contract terms15Accepts the data, admin and handover clauses as written35
Tier or competency10An accreditation or Expert competency in your product52
Weighted score out of 1005387

Partner A gains 6 points on the badge row and gives up 40 across the rows that describe the work, so Partner B wins by 34.

Contract terms to insist on before you sign

Four clauses in the statement of work carry most of the protection.

Data and work product. The HubSpot customer terms already say "You own and retain all rights to the Customer Materials and Customer Data." Extend the same ownership to everything the partner builds from that data: mapping sheets, transformation scripts, cleaned exports, custom code and configuration notes, in editable formats.

Admin credentials. One of your employees holds the top admin account. Partner staff work under named users with the narrowest permissions the job allows, and no login is shared. HubSpot says ending a partner relationship requires removing all partner employees from the client account, so put that step and a deadline in the exit terms.

Subscription. The software subscription, billing and Order Form sit with your company, which keeps the vendor relationship direct whatever happens to the partner.

Documentation handover. List the handover pack, from field dictionary and workflow inventory to integration map and reconciliation report, and tie the final payment to its acceptance. Add exit assistance, so work in progress comes to you if the engagement ends early.

A clean CRM is the base layer for every automation you add later, as our guide to marketing automation in the AI era sets out. For a second opinion on a partner proposal, our agentic AI and automation team is a further resource, and the AI ROI calculator is another for the budget conversation.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Does a higher HubSpot partner tier mean a better CRM implementation?
The tier is a sales and retention measure. HubSpot awards tier points per $100 of monthly recurring revenue a partner sources, assists or manages, and adds average retention minimums at Diamond and Elite. Delivery evidence sits in accreditations, which ask for case studies and a review of the team's qualifications, and in named consultants whose certifications you can check yourself.
How do I check a Salesforce consultant's certifications?
Get each consultant's name and use Salesforce's certification verification tool. Salesforce Help says others see the certification name, dates and description only if the holder's profile is public, so ask the partner to have every named consultant make theirs public before you score the bid. Check the firm's competencies separately, since a competency belongs to the firm.
Should a CRM implementation partner have Super Admin access?
Keep the top admin account with an employee of your company. On HubSpot, partner staff join through an access link and receive Partner Admin permissions, which cannot add, remove or downgrade Super Admins, change billing settings, make payments or manage sensitive data. A partner that needs more than that should explain why in writing and agree an end date.
What should a CRM migration handover include?
A field and property dictionary, the object and association model, an inventory of workflows and automations with an owner for each, an integration map with credentials stored in your own vault, the migration mapping and reconciliation report, and an admin runbook. Put the list in the statement of work and tie the final payment to its acceptance.

Free tools for this topic

FREE TOOLAI Brand Visibility MonitorDoes ChatGPT recommend you — or your competitor?CALCULATORROAS & Break-Even CalculatorKnow the ROAS you actually need before you scale.PLAYBOOKThe AI Search PlaybookGet cited by ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews.

Keep reading

GlossaryWhat Is Marketing Automation in the AI Era?Read →AI & MLThe Governance Operating Model That Lets Marketing Agents Ship Work AloneRead →GlossaryWhat Is Agentic AI? From Chatbots to Autonomous WorkflowsRead →
CATALIST NEWSLETTER

Monthly dose of growth marketing.

Get marketing tips, narratives, guides, and playbooks delivered to your inbox.

Protected by reCAPTCHA — Google's Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.